Compare NHTSA’s frontal crash stars and Overall Vehicle Scores only for vehicles in the same class and within 250 pounds of each other. The program allows side crash and rollover comparisons across classes. Look up both vehicles by their exact model year, then check which rating you’re reading before drawing a conclusion from the stars. NHTSA 5-Star Safety Ratings

Check class and curb weight for frontal and overall scores

NHTSA groups vehicles by class and curb weight, with separate weight classes for passenger cars. Use its categories when checking the two listings. If the model appears in more than one listing, match the version shown before recording the stars. The vehicles must be in the same class and their weights must differ by no more than 250 pounds before you compare the frontal stars. NHTSA vehicle categories and comparison rules

The frontal test uses a fixed barrier to represent a crash between vehicles of similar weight. The Overall Vehicle Score combines injury risk inputs from the frontal and side assessments and the rollover resistance rating. Because the frontal result is part of that score, the same comparison restriction applies to the overall stars. If two vehicles fall outside it, move to the specific results that you can compare across classes. NHTSA frontal test and overall score methodology

Compare matching side and rollover results

The side barrier and side pole tests represent different side impacts. Line up the same side result for each vehicle so you’re comparing the same test. You can also compare rollover ratings across classes. The rollover rating describes a vehicle’s resistance to tipping in the agency’s assessment. Keep side and rollover results in separate rows when you compare them, so each stays tied to its own test. NHTSA side crash and rollover tests

Read safety concerns and unrated entries

Open the details for each model year and read any safety concern flagged next to the stars. NHTSA treats those flags separately from the Overall Vehicle Score, so a high score can appear alongside a specific concern. If a category says “Not Rated,” NHTSA hasn’t tested the vehicle for that crash condition. Leave that comparison blank and work with the results that both listings provide. NHTSA safety ratings FAQ

This guide is general information, not professional advice. Vehicles differ by model, year and trim. Check your owner's manual first, and use a qualified mechanic if you are unsure. You do this work at your own risk.